When a lease comes up for renewal, the easiest option is to let it roll over without a second thought. But renewal should never be automatic. Under current Victorian rental laws, ending a tenancy is no longer as straightforward as simply choosing not to renew, which makes the decision to offer a new lease, and the terms attached to it, one of the more consequential calls a rental provider will make each year.
Property ManagementLease Renewal: What Rental Providers Should Consider
Next ArticleLease Renewal: What Rental Providers Should Consider
28 September 2026
At Marshall White, our Property Management team treats every renewal as a full tenancy review, not a formality. Here is what we assess before making a recommendation.
Current market rent
Before any figure is proposed, the team benchmarks the property against comparable rentals in the area. Renewing at the existing rent without checking the market can leave value on the table, while an increase pitched too high risks losing a good renter over a marginal gain.
Renter history
A tenancy with consistent, on-time payment, respectful communication and proper care of the property is worth protecting. Renewal is often the simplest way to retain a renter who is already looking after the asset well, and the cost of finding and settling a new renter should be weighed against that.
Property condition
A routine inspection ahead of renewal gives a clear picture of how the property is holding up. This informs not just the renewal decision itself, but whether any conditions or works should be built into the new agreement.
Upcoming maintenance
If significant works are planned, timing matters. A shorter lease term may suit a property where renovations or repairs are on the horizon, avoiding disruption to a renter partway through a longer commitment.
The rental provider's future plans
Renewal decisions should always be considered alongside the owner's own intentions. A property being prepared for sale or personal use calls for a different lease length and notice planning than one intended to remain a long-term rental.
Timing
The point in the year at which a lease expires can influence how easily a property would re-let if the renter were to leave. Aligning renewal timing with seasonal demand is a small consideration that can have a meaningful effect on vacancy periods.
Lease length
Twelve months is not always the right default. Renter circumstances, market conditions and the rental provider's plans should all inform whether a shorter or longer term makes more sense this time around.
Current market conditions
Broader conditions, including how quickly properties are leasing locally and the general direction of rents, should shape both the renewal terms offered and how they are negotiated.
The factors above are not assessed in isolation. Our Property Management team looks at the tenancy as a whole and brings a clear recommendation to each rental provider, rather than defaulting to the easiest path. This level of attention protects both the asset and the relationship with the renter over the long term.
To discuss an upcoming lease renewal, contact our Property Management team today.
